Thursday, April 29, 2010

Working with Your Inner Judge: Part II

Last week I focused on how the Inner Judge comes into being and its effects. People have been responding to the survey questions and acknowledging that they have a strong inner judge. They've been asking, "Now that I realize this what should I do with my inner judge? How can I try to get rid of it?" Because it is so painful to have a harsh inner judge we often want to get rid of it. The inner judge came into existence many years ago and has been with you for many years. You are not going to "get rid of it". If you attempt to work with it like this you will create more inner conflict and experience greater pain.

CONVERSATIONS

We have many conversations throughout the day. The most prominent ones are the ones that we have with ourselves. We are so used to our inner voice that sometimes we don't even hear it or recognize it. Sometimes the voice has words, other times it is simply a feeling, such as "I am not good enough" or "I am bad". As such, it is extremely important to be aware of its presence and what it is saying or implying. For example, "you'll never get it right; you're so stupid; you're worthless; you can't do it." Given its false accusations and beliefs and that at this point it is pushing you more than you need or want you can engage in a dialogue with and try to reason with it. Request that it change its role and help you differently. Ask it to ease up and be more understanding and accepting. Explain that you don't need to be pushed and encouraged to the extent that it is doing so. Assertively explain that you are a hard-working and responsible person who is doing the best that she can do and that you can handle things on your own. Cite to yourself and your inner judge what your strengths are.

THE JUDGE AS AN ALLY

Consider what the upside of the inner judge might be. Its intention is likely to try to help you to achieve goals and to make improvements. It may also be attempting to try to keep you safe by inhibiting you from doing dangerous things. In this manner it is attempting to act like a guide who guides you to where you want to go. As such, you can see it as an ally. If you think of it like this you can then thank it for its efforts and acknowledge ways that it has helped you, and continues to help you.


ACTION STEPS:

WAYS TO WORK WITH THE INNER JUDGE

  • Understand how it was formed. This helps to normalize it and to relieve a sense that you are responsible for its existence (although you are not necessarily responsible for its existence you are responsible for how you handle it).
  • Review last month's newsletter to understand how it came into being.
  • Shine a light on it. Become increasingly aware its presence and what it is saying or implying
  • Observe it with detachment, curiosity and interest as though it is separate from you. This will give it less power and give you more autonomy.
  • Listen to what it is saying. Ask yourself is it really true or the judge's opinion. Reflect on your current level of functioning and on what you've accomplished in your life and you will likely see what the judge is saying is not true. Know that opinions are not facts!
  • Reflect on how your have grown through the years and what you have accomplished and write these down.
In sum, having a strong inner judge is common and there are typical ways that it comes into existence. Acknowledging it, being aware of it, thanking it, seeing it as an ally and asking it to take on a different role are some ways to work more effectively with it.

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Monday, April 19, 2010

Power of the Group: The Benefits of Therapy in a Group Format

In the 23 years that I have been facilitating therapy groups, there have been certain consistencies. One is that the experience is helpful, uplifting, and healing for most people who enter the process. I have had the honor of witnessing people utilize group therapy for such diverse benefits as leaving abusive relationships, entering healthy relationships, pursuing dreams, making career changes, breaking patterns of acquiescing to others, learning to identify and meet needs and goals, overcoming addictions, raising self-esteem, overcoming fears, and developing spirituality. Another consistency, however, is that people unfamiliar with group therapy have not understood this unique therapeutic form, and therefore have been reluctant to enter a group.

So, what is a therapy group? Simply stated, it is when a therapist works with several people at once for a common purpose, typically to address common challenges or problems. A group usually has five to ten people, but this can vary. Usually the group meets weekly, though I have also facilitated half-day and all-day groups that meet only once. Members of a therapy group agree that everything said will remain confidential and that the identities of those who attend will also remain confidential. They also agree to relate to one another in a respectful manner. These guidelines contribute to establishing trust and safety, which creates an atmosphere where they feel more comfortable sharing.

Therapists will each facilitate their groups somewhat differently, but to give you a better understanding of what group therapy is like, here’s what I do. I usually start with a check-in, during which each member has about two minutes to say how he or she is, and what their week has been like. I encourage them to be concise and to focus on themselves rather than sharing excessive details. The check-in gives a feel for who might be struggling and who is at ease. Next, participants share their reflections and insights from any previous group meeting, ask questions, and follow up on any unfinished business. I then “open the floor” to see who would like to describe a challenge that he or she is struggling with. Other group members then ask questions to help the person explore the problem, consider different viewpoints, and contemplate solutions. We might use role-playing as well.

Therapy groups can have a particular focus, such as healing from sexual trauma, eating disorders, substance abuse, and other topics. Or, the group can be open to address any challenges or problems that come up. (The latter approach is the one I prefer to facilitate.) Examples of the many issues that group members work on are relationship problems, depression, anxiety, anger management, self-esteem, parenting challenges, sexual addiction, caring for aging parents, divorce, phobias, career difficulties, coping with illness of oneself or a loved one, overcoming procrastination, inability to identify and meet one’s needs, coping with a family member’s addiction, spiritual seeking, feeling unworthy and “empty,” and healing from trauma. Addressing any one of these often improves all aspects of one’s life.

The group process is different in several ways from individual psychotherapy. Here are some examples of what
can emerge from the group process:

Experimenting with new behaviors. The group can be utilized as a laboratory where people can try new behaviors to determine how effective they might be. For example, a person can practice different ways to be supportive, to express anger, to be assertive, or to be vulnerable.

Identifying strengths and weaknesses. Group members help one another discovering weaknesses and strengths. For example, some people believe they are poor communicators. Yet the group might give them input that they, in fact, communicate clearly and directly. This would help a person understand that a perceived weakness is actually a strength. Conversely, a person might believe they communicate clearly. The group might give them input that they are verbose and digressive, and that listening to them results in loss of attention and feelings of frustration. This would help a person to understand that a perceived strength is actually a weakness, and help them to modify their communication style. The group can also validate that one’s perception of strengths and weaknesses are accurate.

Learning conflict resolution skills. As in any group of people, conflict arises in the therapeutic group. By focusing on the group process in the present moment, members learn healthy conflict resolution skills. In fact, discussing the dynamics and tendencies of the group is often more valuable than discussing the specifics of situations the members bring to the sessions.

Normalizing feelings and problems. When a person talks about a painful struggle, an abusive past, or actions they aren’t happy about, others in the group often reveal similar stories or feelings. Clients repeatedly say, “I never knew others felt this way,” or “It’s such a relief to know I’m not alone.” This revelation decreases their sense of isolation and shame. Shame can be more damaging to the person than the problem that produced it.

Re-creating and working through patterns. Groups serve as a microcosm of society. How a person acts, communicates, and relates to others in a therapy group is very likely how they behave at work, at home, with friends, in their family, and so on. I have seen this many times. An example is a person who interrupts and talks over others. By identifying this behavior in the group, and hearing how it affects others, the person learns that this is a destructive pattern. The group session often reveals that interrupting is a manifestation of anxiety, or a strong need to be heard. The group and I will help the person learn to be more patient and to respond in healthy, respectful, and effective ways.

Discovering family roles. Groups are also like a family. Members tend to “play out” roles they have played in their family of origin (the one they grew up in). Someone who has grown up in a dysfunctional family has learned unhealthy behaviors and coping mechanisms. The group enables such a person to understand the role she or he plays, and to modify it as needed. Examples of this would be acting as caretaker, mediator, scapegoat, hero, victim, parent, or child. Or, the person may be overly aggressive/assertive, or overly passive. It is fascinating to see how these roles carry through into daily life outside the family, and it is uplifting to see people modify them once they recognize the pattern.

Through the years of facilitating groups, I have seen how committed participants become to their own growth and development, as well as to that of the other group members. One reflection of this is that they come to hold others accountable while also taking responsibility for their own growth. As a result, members attend sessions quite consistently. That increases the connection among them, which elevates their trust and willingness to share openly and honestly. They learn to give and receive honest and constructive feedback. They also learn important group skills, such as effective conflict resolution and negotiation skills, a willingness to try new things, and getting one’s needs met in a healthy manner. What’s more, the group therapy participants have been able to take these newly developed skills and insights back into their lives, and become happier and healthier people.



Friday, April 16, 2010

Understanding Your Inner Judge: Part I

Many people who I work with and who I know personally struggle with having a strict inner critic or judge. They wonder how this came into being and what its effects are.

THE INNER JUDGE:
  • is consistently punitive,harsh, critical, condemning and belittling.
  • has an incessant demand for better conduct and more achievement.
  • is overly strict, punitive and forbidding and therefore restricts freedom of action
  • is an internalization of parental and societal disapproval and rebuke.
  • is often unconscious which makes it more powerful, hurtful and insidious.

WHO THE INNER JUDGE BECOMES ESTABLISHED IN:

Children who grew up with parents and/or caregivers, including teachers and spiritual advisors, who were consistently critical, condemning and belittling, intolerant of short comings, intolerant of children simply being or acting like children, intrusive of physical and/or emotionally and/or sexual boundaries, narcissistic and egocentric (essentially they were overly involved with themselves and could not focus on their child) and emotionally distant, who exploited their children, could not provide emotional nurturance, who put forth incessant demands for better conduct and more achievement, yelled and screamed, had rigid expectations and who unfavorably compared their child to others.

EFFECTS OF THE INNER JUDGE

Having a strong inner judge and this type of personality structure results in high levels of anxiety, depression and guilt, all of which contributes to disturbances of mood. Quite often a person may feel like
this and not know why. As such, it is a “free floating” pain not necessarily associated with an event or situation. It results in feeling low grade anger and/or in bursts of fury. The anger will often exceed what the situation warrants. It manifests as hopelessness and chronic disappointment. Even when on the surface there is reason to be hopeful a person isn't and even when things are going well a person will feel chronically disappointed. Because there are consistent unrealistic expectations a person is set up for failure. They simply cannot succeed because their expectations are unrealistic and unachievable.

No matter what one does it is not enough, no matter how one is, it is not good enough, no matter how one performs they feel like they fall short. Because a person is afraid to fail or make a mistake they often don’t take action (this might even include something that is fun). People will also believe that they are making
mistakes when they aren’t. They will think that they did poorly on a test or with a presentation yet their grade or feedback will contradict this. Yet, when positive feedback is given it is often disbelieved. Or they may be overly afraid of making mistakes. This fear will often prevent them from taking healthy action. And they often feel that the job they are doing will be criticized.

Once again no matter what they do or how they are or how things are it is not good enough. A person may fee chronically guilty about what they are, or not, doing. This could be simply when they are caring for themselves, setting healthy limits or saying no to a request. A person with a strong inner critic also has difficulty relaxing and having fun. There is an underlying sense of dis-ease and dread. When someone wants to spend time with them they feel unworthy and question the person’s motivation. They might ask themselves, “Why would anyone want to spend time with me?; Other people see and feel their
goodness yet they cannot. Also very present is a very strong sense of shame. It is important to differentiate between guilt and shame. Guilt relates to feeling badly about what someone does or does not do while shame is related to who someone is and how they feel about themselves. What we do varies and fluctuates. Who we are and how we feel about ourselves is more permanent.

As such, while guilt and shame are both painful, shame is the deeper and more pervasive pain. So, as you can see, there is an explanation for how the inner judge comes into being and for the pain that it causes.


ACTION STEPS / SUGGESTIONS

  • Reflect on whether you have a strict inner judge.
  • Become increasingly aware of it.
  • Discern between who is making the decision-you or the inner judge. When you have a decision to make.
  • Observe it with curiosity and interest. Being aware of it will give it less power and give you more autonomy.